A city of sadness will not satisfy those seeking a political expose, but hous refusal to trivialize events for the sake of emotional appeal gives the film a universality of spirit that ensures its place among the most powerful cinematic statements of our time. Analysis of the movie a city of sadness 812 words cram. A city of sadness 1989 is a landmark film in the taiwanese new wave as it was the first film made in taiwan that dealt with the 228 incident and the beginning of martial law in 1949 that didnt end until 1987. Obviously more time is needed to completely process hou hsiaohsiens masterful achievement screened on a wonderful new 35mm print documenting the tensions between mainland china and taiwan during the 19451949 time period that ultimately produced the. In the night i slept after i exhausted my fingers i understood that the self that completely escaped my body mounted my. The dissection of these particular sequences in a city of sadness leads to the conclusion that a large measure of the film s import rests on the fact that just as political repression is a form of silencing, the silent witness wenqing fourth brother enacts the very problem of communication which the february 28 incident creates and the.
The film climaxes with the notorious incident of february 28, 1947, a tiananmen squarestyle massacre of native taiwanese committed by kuomintang troops resulting in between 18,000 to 28,000. A city of sadness takes place in the time between japans ceding of taiwan and the nationalist chinese government occupying the island as its last stronghold. One of the film s central characters, played by tony leung, is a deaf photographer whose speech is intertitled. How lost city of z director james gray is fighting for the future of cinema. Jiufen was the venue where the awardwinning venice golden lion winner film a city of sadness. In 1989 a city of sadness won the golden lion, the venice film festivals award for best picture. In 1989, following the end of taiwans 40 years of martial law, a city of sadness became the first public reference to the previously taboo 228 incident, a massacre of local protesters in february 1947 by the kmt the ruling political party and subsequent purges which took over 20,000 lives. The first taiwanese film shot in direct sound, a city of sadness echoes the forgotten voices of ordinary people facing political repression. This poetic masterpiece changed the way i view cinema. Seen through the prism of the lin family, this complex family drama from taiwanese master hou hsiao hsien details a brief but crucial moment in taiwanese history between 1945, when 50 years of japanese colonial rule came to an end, and 1949, when chiang kaisheks nationalist kuomintang forces established a governmentinexile after the communist army captured mainland china. The coronavirus crisis in seattle is a major threat to the stranger s ability to keep the city informed. This intimate epic chronicles the tragedies that befall the three lin brothersa gangster, a translator for the japanese administration, and a. No matter how good you whistle, a human is a type of sheep that wont come. A city of sadness is a great film, one that will be watched as long as there are people who care about the movies as an art.
Eleanor oliphant is completely fine is the 2017 debut novel of gail honeyman, and the winner of the 2017 costa debut novel award the novel focuses on 29yearold eleanor oliphant, a social misfit with a traumatic past who becomes enamoured of a singer, whom she believes she is destined to be with. Most of the films dialog is either in the taiwanese dialect distinct from mandarin or japanese taiwan was a japanese colony between 18951945, since thats what native taiwanese at the time generally spoke. Navy seal jocko willink breaks down combat scenes from movies. A study of history, culture, and gender in hou hsiaohsiens film a city of sadness germany. Indeed, this film has a lot similarities to godfather, in which the most notable is the condensation of an entire nation into the life of one single family. This vastly ambitious drama about political strife in taiwan distills a crucial historical periodfrom the islands liberation from japan, in 1945, to the communist takeover. Its hard to follow but waves of nostalgia were hitting me from all sorts of places. The setting is then faintly illuminated by the warm glow of candles to reveal an anxious taiwanese household that is preparing for the. It is this resigned sentiment of irrevocable separation that is reflected in the films sustained elegiac tone, observed by berenice reynaud in her comment. Yet a city of sadness is no ordinary historical film, as neither the incident nor the slaughter are depicted. Its successor two years later, city of sadness, marks another watershed, as the first film explicitly concerned with taiwanese history, from which viewpoint it can be seen as the first of a loose trilogy, followed by the puppetmaster 1993, and completed with.
Probably not, as the film only uses tin shui wai as a setting and doesnt really connect its portrait of crappy lives to anything more telling about the town or its situation. Skip other details including permanent urls, doi, citation information. The film constantly implies that violence is happening, but never shows it in the foreground. How lost city of z director james gray is fighting for the. A cinematic behemoth, something grand, incomplete, and sweeping. Spirited away at the city of sadness jiufen, taipei. Dec 08, 20 with a city of sadness, hou takes on a far broader historical canvas. Museum of the moving image visit calendar a city of. Hou hsiaohsien made this film after directing nine features in taiwan and was awarded the prestigious golden lion at the 1989 venice film festival. A city of sadness by berenice reynaud senses of cinema. Institute of modern history, academia sinica, 1992. Because no light enters the inside of my eyes, this is where the film is alive. Oct 12, 2014 with tony leung chiuwai, hsin shufen, li tienlu, jack kao.
The film was the first to deal openly with the kmts authoritarian misdeeds after its 1945 takeover. City of sadness was highly acknowledged by the film critics around the world. Hous beautiful, tragic, and ineffably moving city is, one of the supreme masterworks of the contemporary cinema jonathan rosenbaum. It tells the story of a family embroiled in the white terror that was. A city of sadness is a 1989 taiwanese drama film, by hou hsiaohsien. Having been advertised as a film about the february 28 incident but never explicitly depicting the event, the film was consequently criticized as politically ambiguous, as well as overly difficult to follow. Why anyone who cares about taiwan should watch a city of. Made in hong kong region a bluray english subtitled. How lost city of z director james gray is fighting for. Also sign me up for fanmail to get updates on all things movies. However, its portrait of wayward youth is a harrowing and even compelling one.
A city of sadness depicts a feeling, which is whats important here not necessarily the plot. Mar 27, 2016 the dissection of these particular sequences in a city of sadness leads to the conclusion that a large measure of the film s import rests on the fact that just as political repression is a form of silencing, the silent witness wenqing fourth brother enacts the very problem of communication which the february 28 incident creates and the. Now, i dont want to say that i dismiss this way of narration but a city of sadness does not need such a narrator. It tells the story of a family embroiled in the white terror that was wrought on the taiwanese people by the kuomintang government after their arrival from mainland china in the late 1940s, during which thousands of taiwanese and recent emigres from the mainland were rounded up, shot, andor sent to prison.
Its successor two years later, city of sadness, marks another watershed, as the first film explicitly concerned with taiwanese history, from which viewpoint it can be seen as the first of a loose trilogy, followed by the puppetmaster 1993, and completed with good men, good women 1995. Berenice reynaud deciphers the complex social and historical threads that combine in the film while analysing its aesthetics in the context of hous entire career. In fact, the only true closeup of the film is of a photograph wenching is touching up. An individual experiencing sadness may become quiet or lethargic, and withdraw themselves from others. Normally you would have a narrator who is telling you the story from his point of view. Hous now trademark style went on to influence a lot of people. Bei qing cheng shi a city of sadness 1989 rotten tomatoes. Though a city of sadness was the first film to ever depict 228, it does so in a rather indirect way.
Dec 18, 2011 a city of sadness takes place in the time between japans ceding of taiwan and the nationalist chinese government occupying the island as its last stronghold. When it won the prestigious golden lion award at the venice international film festival, a city of sadness became too famous to silence and went on to be a box office hit at home. Apr 04, 2018 the coronavirus crisis in seattle is a major threat to the stranger s ability to keep the city informed. In 1989, hou hsiaohsiens a city of sadness beiqing chengshi won the golden lion award in venice. In this transitory moment, marked by rapid changes in policy and law, the country was passed from one colonizing force to another, standing on the brink of being captured by yet another.
Calendar a city of sadness museum of the moving image. City of sadness 1989 hsiaohsien hou, hou hsiao hsien. Even though i never really come to love other hous films, city of sadness is a flawless epic that truthfully depict an era that is forgotten by most of my generation. A city of sadness 1989 soon after japan relinquishes control of taiwan in 1945, the lin brothers face hardships from the changing culture. A city of sadness is a 1989 taiwanese historical drama film directed by hou hsiaohsien. Within that framework, you could claim that a city of sadness is a movie about native taiwanese after all, its protagonist family falls into that category. Some families may have a conscious or unconscious rule that sadness is not allowed, but robin skynner has suggested that this may cause problems, arguing that with sadness screened off, people can become shallow and manic. Speaking from experience, you shouldnt whistle at your mom.
Enter your location to see which movie theaters are playing a city of sadness near you. Apr 10, 2017 james gray is a filmmaker out of timein the absolutely best senseand thats reconfirmed by the lost city of z, his adaptation of david granns nonfiction book about early 20th century. A city of sadness opens with a credit sequenceshot of total darkness as the solemn voice of emperor hirohito is heard over a radio broadcast announcing the unconditional surrender of japan on august 15, 1945. Given the history and setting of this place, on second thought, the rain and mist set a very nice ambience for my first visit to this city of sadness. A city of sadness was a major commercial success in taiwan, but critics were largely ambivalent toward the work. A city of sadness remains a powerful piece of work, and one of the. Outside in leaves the city behind filmtv the stranger.
An example of severe sadness is depression, a mood which can be brought on by major depressive disorder or persistent. Loaded with detail and elliptically structured to let viewers make their own connections, hous film spans four fateful years of transition in taiwan, from the defeat of the japanese colonialists. Hou was named best director, but the film was beaten to the top prize by. A city of sadness 1989 a city of sadness 1989 user. Have you ever whistled at a girl on a rainy street. For example, in one scene, a character languishes in prison and his. A city of sadness is the first part of director hou hsiaohsiens trilogy on taiwanese history. Does besieged city really succeed as a portrait of tin shui wai, the city of sadness. As the first taiwanese movie that received the highest. Berenice reynaud deciphers the complex social and historical threads that combine in the film while analysing its.
The film won the golden lion at the 1989 venice film festival. The first chineselanguage film to ever win the venice film festivals golden lion award, hou hsiaohsiens a city of sadness is the story of. The first film made in taiwan that dealt with the 228 incident and the beginning of martial law in 1949 that didnt end until 1987. City of sadness hou hsiaohsien, 1989 the first film in taiwanese director hou hsiaohsiens trilogy about his countrys modern history, city of sadness is an ambitiously conceived, sometimes frustratingly elliptical family chronicle that shows one familys experience immediately following the japanese occupation of the nation. The soundtrack is composed and played by japanese instrumental unit. This beautiful family saga by the great taiwanese filmmaker hou hsiaohsien begins in 1945, when japan ended its 51year colonial rule in taiwan, and concludes in 1949, when mainland china became.
A city of sadness is a great film, one that will be watched as long as there are people who care about movies as an art. A city of sadness 1989 is a landmark film in the taiwanese new wave. It tells the story of a family embroiled in the white terror that. In a city of sadness, movie director hou hsiaohsien vividly captures the despair of the taiwanese through the lin family following the surrender of japan in 1945 to when the nationalist party completely retreats to taiwan after losing the mainland to the communist party in 1949. Sadness is an emotional pain associated with, or characterized by, feelings of disadvantage, loss, despair, grief, helplessness, disappointment and sorrow. And city of sadness is the film that crystallized his approach to cinematic narration. British film institute, 2002 berenice reynauds study of hou hsiaohsiens a city of sadness is a welcome addition to the bfis modern classics series, not only because hous film is an asian presence rarely found in the series but also because it is truly a modern classic, being a key film for anyone interested.
30 174 1318 1301 560 1127 1007 258 734 1427 653 178 348 381 1171 905 1605 928 500 1548 202 1453 992 620 988 573 1136 1290